The debate on Shoreline Mitigation with Large Woody Debris heats up!
The debate over dock mitigation using Large Woody Debris (LWD) in Lake Chelan is heating up. Large Woody Debris are usually bundles of old apple trees which are anchored to the bottom of Lake Chelan to supposedly mitigate for the impact of building a dock.
Washington Administrative Code, WAC 220-110-060, requires no net loss of habitat for a hydraulic project (in this case, a dock). In earlier public meetings on the Shorelines Master Plan Update currently underway with Chelan County, expert biologists were brought in to discuss fisheries mitigation on Lake Chelan stated that the LWD currently being specified for mitigation probably favored the predator species of those that are supposedly being attempted to be protected. In fact, are likely to help fish habitat rather than hurt it.
A detailed discussion of the issue can be found at the Lake Chelan Sailing Association Web site at sailchelan.com. The issue goes beyond the expense and effectiveness of LWD structures for fish habitat. The LWD structures pose potential hazards for navigation and swimmers including potential liability for possible injury or death. The unique circumstances of Lake Chelan, where our shorelines don’t have vegitation and the water level is lowered as much as 21 feet every year are such that the types of things that might benefit other waterways are not applicable to Lake Chelan.
More recently, Russ Jones at the LCSA has started a forum on the topic of LWD at Lake Chelan that details some of the recent happenings.
One of the recent events is Mike Kaputa at the Chelan County Department of Natural Resources is working to set up a “fee in lieu” program for permit holders. That program would allow an applicant for a dock permit to pay a fee into a larger off-site mitigation project rather than put bundles of mature apple trees on their property in Lake Chelan.
Based on the feedback on the forum, the public wants to understand why there should be any mitigation required at all for a project which doesn’t cause any net loss of habitat to begin with. Also, last week the state Department of Natural Resources has taken a position that they don’t want any LWD placed on land under their stewardship (all land below the 1079′ elevation at Lake Chelan) as well as a host of new regulations they are preparing to implement administratively.
Meanwhile, property owners who are hoping to construct docks this year are at a loss as to what they should do. Do they implement probably harmful, dangerous and unsightly LWD structures, wait for a fee-in-lieu program or just wait to see if a sensible alternative develops? It is understandable that people who are trying to get things done are frustrated by the lack of accountability and responsiveness from the Department of Fish and Wildlife and the Department of Natural Resources.
If you are own or are looking at Lake Chelan Waterfront homes or property, be sure to stay informed!



























